The Opinion Line: A great teaching tool for in-person and virtual learning!
Updated: Jan 14, 2024
Are you looking for a way to break up your lesson and get students both thinking and moving? Try an opinion line! An opinion line is a real or imaginary line that you make in your classroom, then once you read a statement which can be agreed or disagreed with the students get up and stand on the line where their opinion falls. If they strongly agree with the statement then they stand under the "strongly agree" sign, if they strongly disagree then they stand under the "strongly disagree" sign and since the line is a continuum they can stand anywhere in-between. You can then ask students to explain why they chose a specific location on the line and share their opinion with the class, since it is an opinion-based activity there is no right or wrong answer so students often feel more comfortable taking risks.
Steps for an In-Person Opinion Line:
If you are interested in using an Opinion Line in your classroom, here are the things to prepare:
#1 : Make sure you have a controversial or multi-faceted topic to discuss in class, I love using Opinion lines for genetics, cloning & stem cells, it is very useful in advisory when talking about student choices in scenarios regarding peer interaction and making choices about things like smoking as well as for topics like Climate Change.
#2 : Ensure that your students learn enough about the topic to have an opinion that they can defend with reasonable evidence. For example, before doing an Opinion Line about Tipping Points for climate change I had my students read this Nature article for homework and answer some questions.
#3 : Put the Opinion line cards (free to download in the link below) on the wall or board, using tape or ideally magnets on my whiteboards. I printed these cards out and then laminated them so I can pull them out to use them whenever I decide to do an Opinion Line activity. You can also just write the words" Strongly Agree", "Strongly Disagree" and "Neither Agree nor disagree" directly on the board or on pieces of paper to put up.
#4 : Put together your Opinion line statements, I usually use from 3 - 5 different statements and have them build upon each other, I also have found that having them written on a slide and projected helps students keep better track of what they are agreeing or disagreeing with. Some students really struggle with oral instructions so having the statements on the board is an easy and effective scaffold. You can see the statements I used for the Tipping Points Opinion Line in the image below. I set up my slide with animations so only one statement shows up a time.
#5 : Go over behavioral expectations with your students, you want them to step back from the line whenever a new statement is posted/read, I often have them go to the back of the room just to reset themselves. You should also be clear that you will call on students to defend why they have chosen that place along the line. I use a random name generator or popsicle sticks with students names on them to choose the students.
#6 : Have fun with your Opinion line! It's a great way to generate interesting discussions and get students moving.
A virtual Option: Padlet!
If you are looking to do a virtual opinion line a great website to use is Padlet, you can see a screenshot below of a "shelf" I put together on Padlet. This free website is very interactive, you can post the link and your students can login and post comments. I made a shelf with 3 columns, one for Strongly Agree, on for Neither Agree nor Disagree and one for Strongly disagree. You can see sample student posts in the white boxes below. This way students can share their opinions for each statement and you can have them explain/defend their choices in a Zoom or Google Meets call. While I hope the days of virtual school are long gone, it's always a good idea to have a backup!
I hope you found this post helpful!
Thanks for reading teachers, travelers and curious souls of all kinds.
The Roaming Scientist
The subject of connecting historical names with local education feels more interesting when there is room for a reader to stop and ask their own questions. A school's name can provide a route into discussing a wider historical period. Seen this way, Jagiellonian history education becomes a topic to explore rather than something to sum up too quickly. I am still thinking through the details, and a small example would help me picture how this works in practice. How can students explore a historical figure without reducing the lesson to a list of dates?
Thinking about making health information easier to understand, I find the smaller practical questions more interesting than a quick conclusion. Plain language can help readers recognise what a health explanation does and does not establish. I would keep that thought nearby when looking for ideas about health information literacy. The part I would like to explore further is what happens when the idea meets a real situation with its own limitations. What makes a health information page understandable to someone without specialist knowledge?
The topic of learning from subject specialists gives me a few things to think about, especially when the discussion moves beyond general advice. A specialist's example can show how a broad principle applies to a particular problem. That is the kind of detail I would keep in mind while exploring expert learning guidance. The part I would like to explore further is what happens when the idea meets a real situation with its own limitations. What makes an expert explanation useful to someone with little background knowledge?
What draws my attention to building connections through Grabow community projects is the possibility of making an unfamiliar subject feel closer to everyday life. A shared project can bring together people who know different parts of a town's story. It gives me a more concrete starting point for thinking about Grabow community learning. I do not have a settled view yet, but this seems like a good place to slow down and look more closely. How can students make a community project useful beyond the classroom?
The topic of exploring local history and learning in Bytow gives me a few things to think about, especially when the discussion moves beyond general advice. Local places can give a history lesson a setting that students can picture for themselves. This is why I would approach Bytow local history with a specific question rather than a fixed expectation. I would probably come back to this question after trying to work through one concrete example rather than deciding immediately. Which everyday landmarks would make a good starting point for a local history project?